HP vs HG Day 1

The “Likability” of the Main Character

Harry Potter – Harry was easy to like. He was courageous and always stuck up for his friends. He wasn’t super cool and he wasn’t cocky. He wasn’t amazing at everything, and because of that, many readers bonded with him as the unlikely hero, one who had been thrust into his position. He represented everything that was good straight from the start, from the goodness of his parents to their great love. 

Hunger Games – Katniss was likable at first. Everybody respected her for her courage to volunteer for Prim and the wonderful description of her certainly helped – her brown hair and her olive skin, etc. etc. People liked the strong female protagonist concept and the fact that she could fend for herself. However, going through the books, she became less and less likable and Peeta more and more. And if you don’t like the main character, the books are less satisfying. Because the main character has this great obstacle to overcome, the readers must be invested in the protagonist to overcome and win. By the end of the series, however, readers were getting annoyed with Katniss and due to this, they stopped caring about what happened. She became incredibly paranoid about who to trust and who not to trust. She did not trust Peeta or anyone else in her life that tried to help her. She pushed everyone away. She was selfish and would put everyone else’s life on the line. For example, the ending of Hunger Games. When it was told that there would only be one winner, she automatically wanted to kill Peeta. Peeta, on the other hand, had something entirely different planned. That is a powerful insight into her character. 

There is a huge emphasis on the likability of the main character. Even if the main character is evil and awful, the author has to try and spin it so that the reader always sides with them. It’s difficult to enjoy a book in which most of the time is spent in exasperation over the faults of the main character. That is my first reason as to why I like Harry Potter better!

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “HP vs HG Day 1

  1. Katniss got annoying for me after a while; she and her love struggles. If I was in her situation, I would forget about choosing which guy and put in all my energy to save Panem.

    • Yes. I love that Rowling put the plot and the future of the greater society above the love interests of the character – heck, there wasn’t any love relationships until like the 5th book, while it seemed Collins used Katniss’s relationship to send readers in a fan shipping frenzy and therefore, generate more popularity.

  2. aspenlinmer says:

    I agree. I related much, much more with Harry than with Katniss. In fact after a while i was annoyed with Katniss…where as the more I got to know Harry the more I could understand why he did what he did. I really related to how he felt as well when his mind was spinning with possibilities.

    ~Aspen

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s